Holy Cow Cake Recipe

Holy Cow Cake Recipe on MyHumbleHomeandGarden.com

What is a ‘Holy Cow Cake’?  Well, until this past week, I had never even heard of it!  It certainly piqued my interest when it was one of the options offered by a caterer.

Jon-Michael and Emily have reserved The Barn at Cedar Grove, which is amazing and located three hours south of here in south central Kentucky, for their fall wedding next year.  This week, we visited Amy at the restored tobacco barn to go over some of the details and ask for her recommendations for local vendors.  Amy is amazing!

She recommended some local caterers.  The first on our list, Longhunters in Greensburg, Kentucky, was where we stopped for a chat with Justine to see what they had to offer.  Longhunters is such a quaint little coffee and tea shop.  We had lunch and looked over options on their catering menu.

Holy Cow Cake was one of the dessert options.  It caught my eye and I had to look it up and find out exactly what it was.  There are several versions of this using cake mixes from yellow, German chocolate, to a variety of other chocolate cakes.  Holy Cow Cake on MyHumbleHomeandGarden.com

For this recipe, you will need a cake mix and the eggs, oil, and liquid for making it.  I used a chocolate fudge cake mix.  In addition to the ingredients listed on the cake mix box, you will need a 12-ounce jar of caramel topping, sweetened condensed milk, an 8-ounce package of cream cheese, an 8-ounce tub of Cool Whip, and Butterfinger candy bars.  (I also added flour to the cake mix.)



Holy Cow Cake Recipe on MyHumbleHomeandGarden.com

Remember when cake mixes weighed 18 – ounces?  Have you noticed all the boxes have been down-sized?   Yet the prices seem to continue to rise.  Well, I read about a way to achieve that 18 – ounce cake mix by adding all-purpose flour to a cake mix.  The resulting cake is a little firmer and a little less crumbly and will work in those old recipes calling for the 18-ounce mix.  


In this case, I thought the extra flour making a firmer cake would hold up better with the extra milk and caramel.

In order to make a cake that tastes a little more homemade, I also use milk instead of water.  We did not have extra large eggs on this occasion, so I added one extra ‘large’ egg.  (I usually use ‘extra large’ eggs for baking.)

Holy Cow Cake

(1) 15.25-oz. box Chocolate Fudge Cake Mix

6 Tblsp. all-purpose flour

Vegetable oil

Extra large eggs

Heat the oven to 360°.  Follow the instructions for the box cake, except add and whisk 6 tablespoons of all-purpose flour into the cake mix and substitute milk for the water.  Use the suggested amount of vegetable oil and use extra large eggs. (I didn’t have extra large so I added 1 egg.)Holy Cow Cake Recipe on MyHumbleHomeandGarden.com

Mix on medium for 2 minutes and transfer to prepared 9″ x 13″ pan.  (Grease the bottom of the pan or line the pan with non-stick foil.)* See Below

(We are an Amazon Affiliate.  If you purchase through the link above, we will receive a small percentage of the sale.)

 Bake in the preheated oven for about 30 minutes.

Holy Cow Cake Recipe on MyHumbleHomeandGarden.com


While the cake is baking, mix a can of sweetened condensed milk and a 12 oz. jar of caramel sauce together in a bowl.  Set aside.

Remove the cake from the oven and poke holes in the cake with a wooden spoon handle or a chopstick.Holy Cow Cake Recipe on MyHumbleHomeandGarden.com

Pour the condensed milk and caramel mixture over the top of the warm chocolate cake.  Allow the cake to cool completely.  The milk and caramel mixture will be absorbed into the cake.  (I forgot to add a layer of the crushed Butterfingers here.  Although this cake was good anyway, I think that would have been a nice extra layer.)


8-oz. pkg. of cream cheese, softened

8-oz. Cool Whip

1 tsp. Vanilla extract

Beat the softened cream cheese and the vanilla with a mixer until smooth.  Add the Cool Whip a little at a time, beating until completely combined.Holy Cow Cake Recipe on MyHumbleHomeandGarden.com

Spread evenly over the top of the cake.





Place the Butterfinger candy bars in a plastic freezer bag and pound with a rolling pin or meat mallet to break into small pieces.  Spread across the top of the cake.Holy Cow Cake Recipe on MyHumbleHomeandGarden.com

Refrigerate for at least 3 hours or overnight.



Holy Cow Cake Recipe on MyHumbleHomeandGarden.com




   * Click here ►for Dreaded Cake Doming Prevention using bake-even strips.  I wanted a flat cake so I used the bake-even strips.  Perfect!  (We are an affiliate of Amazon and if you purchase through this link, we will receive a small percentage at no cost to you.  Thanks for supporting this website!)Holy Cow Cake Recipe on MyHumbleHomeandGarden.com





Lining the pan with the Reynold’s Non-stick foil made it so easy to remove from the pan!   Cutting the cake into perfect squares was a breeze!Holy Cow Cake Recipe on MyHumbleHomeandGarden.comHoly Cow Cake!  This cake was really pretty simple to make and the results, a really moist, delicious, caramel flavored chocolate fudge cake topped with a taste of Butterfinger.

Holy Cow Cake Recipe on MyHumbleHomeandGarden.com

Please follow and like us:

Share your thoughts?

Enjoy this blog? Please spread the word :)